Black Water

Starring Edward Norton, Naomi Watts and Liev Schreiber. Directed by John Curran
Running Time: 123 mins
Rated: Rated M (moderate themes and sexual references)
A film for an adult audience that can be recommended both for its fine technical qualities and for its explorations of themes of infidelity, reconciliation, forgiveness and atonement.

W. Somerset Maugham created several strong female characters in his novels. (Films and telemovies from his writings already number 98,) There was Sadie Thompson in Rain (portrayed on screen by Gloria Swanson, Joan Crawford and Rita Hayworth) who, in isolated and tropical settings, tormented a man of God. There was the unfaithful Leslie Crosbie of The Letter, again in the tropics, (portrayed on screen by Jeanne Eagels, Bette Davis and Lee Remick). There was the unfaithful Mildred Rogers of Of Human Bondage (portrayed on screen by Bette Davis, Eleanor Parker and Kim Novak).

His Kitty Wane in The Painted Veil is a less forceful character than these - and she has been portrayed by Greta Garbo, Eleanor Parker and, now, Naomi Watts. However, she too is unfaithful but she has the opportunity to redeem herself - and be redeemed by her husband and his work among cholera victims.

Maugham, who trained and qualified as a doctor, was also interested in religious and spiritual themes in such works as The Razor's Edge where a man goes in search of himself in the East.

This version of The Painted Veil was filmed in China. The cinematography of Shanghai and of the mountains and rivers of South China make a magnificent background to the plot. Alexandre Desplat's evocative score won a Golden Globe award.

The setting is 1925, China. Flashbacks build up the story of the western man and woman being carried through the countryside on chairs. He is a shy and rather uptight bacteriologist from England (Edward Norton most persuasive in the role) and his socialite and spoiled young wife, Kitty (Naomi Watts proving that she is an actress of skill and substance). We soon learn that she did not love her husband despite his devotion to her and has had a dalliance with a worthless diplomat (Liev Schreiber) in Shanghai. Her husband volunteers to go to a remote village to help in a cholera epidemic and, quietly vengeful, forces his wife to accompany him.

The film develops the themes of colonialist presence in China and the growing resentment and violent protests as well as the themes of Chinese need for contemporary medical practice and hygiene. In the village are a group of French nuns who run an orphanage and who are helping in the crisis, many of them dying. Diana Rigg plays the superior, a practical and devout woman who delivers some very moving dialogue about her vocation, her love of God, her passion for God and how as she has grown older, they are like an old married couple sitting together, taking each other for granted, a maturing up and down love.

The plot develops as might be expected, especially in the tense relationship between husband and wife, in the hard work of the doctor, in the passive aggression of the military chief who finally breaks through the rituals and pride of the local warlord to change the practices of the people concerning the dead which are contributing to the spread of the disease.

The end of the film is moving, showing that hard circumstances and shared self-giving can transcend bitterness and hurt and that love and forgiveness are not impossible.

Ron Nyswaner (Philadelphia) can be proud of the screenplay he has written and John Curran (Praise, We Don't Liver Here Anymore) proud of the film he has directed.

Paramount Out April 24

Fr Peter Malone MSC directs the film desk of SIGNIS: the World Association of Catholic Communicators, and is an associate of the Australian Catholic Office for Film & Broadcasting.


Online and off line payment options
Major credit cards accepted


GPO Box 368
Canberra ACT 2601
Australia

1300 4FAITH (1300 432 484)
Catholic Enquiry Centre

Back to top